If you're on the hunt for a sandwich shop that doesn’t just slap some meat between two slices of bread but instead crafts a work of art, Fatty Lumpkin's Sandwich Shack is where you need to be. Their menu is stacked with mouthwatering options that bring together quality ingredients, bold flavors, and an undeniable homemade touch.
Italian Hoagies – A Flavor Explosion
These sandwiches are all about hearty meats and rich cheeses. Whether you go for the Top Round Roast Beef & Cheese, the Salami & Cheese, or the ultimate Fatty Turkey & Cheese, every bite is a perfect balance of savory, smoky, and slightly tangy goodness. If you can’t decide between turkey and salami, why not have both? The Salami, Turkey & Cheese hoagie gives you the best of both worlds.
Fatty's Classics & Gourmet Specialties – Signature Sandwiches with a Twist
Fatty Lumpkin’s doesn’t stop at the classics. Their gourmet specialties include the Sky High Pastrami on Rye, which is a towering stack of tender pastrami with just the right amount of spice. If you're in the mood for something bold, the Wham Bam Thank You Ham is a standout, packed with rich, smoky ham layered with flavors that demand attention. K.C.'s Kickin' Chicken and Clucky You bring the heat with juicy, perfectly seasoned chicken, while the Chix Love Salad offers a lighter, yet equally satisfying, option.
The Reuben Family Tree – A Must-Try for Reuben Fans
For those who swear by a good Reuben, Bert’s Beach is a delicious twist on the classic, taking corned beef, tangy sauerkraut, and melty cheese to a whole new level.
Salads & Sides – Fresh and Flavorful
If you're craving something crisp and refreshing, their salads don’t disappoint. The Caesar, Buffalo Chicken, Fatty’s Chef, Caprese, and TL’s Greek Island salads are packed with fresh ingredients and bold dressings. And don’t forget a side of fresh fruit to balance out the meal!
Beverages – The Perfect Pairing
Whether it’s an Old School Bottle & Can soda, Fresh Brewed Iced Tea, Lemonade, or a hot cup of Fresh Brewed Coffee, there’s something to complement every bite.
Every sandwich at Fatty Lumpkin’s Sandwich Shack isn’t just a meal—it’s an experience. From stacked hoagies to loaded classics, every bite delivers on quality, freshness, and flavor.